Review of “Operation Mincemeat”

In 1943, an innovative plan by British intelligence, known as MI6, aimed to deceive Adolf Hitler regarding the Allied invasion plans. This scheme, dubbed “Operation Mincemeat,” involved tricking Hitler into believing an invasion would occur in Greece and Sardinia, rather than Sicily, which was heavily fortified by Nazi Germany. The operation utilized the body of a homeless man from London, who had succumbed to rat poison. A briefcase filled with forged invasion plans for Sardinia was attached to the body, which was then submerged near Spain. At the time, Spain was rife with Nazi spies, making it a strategic location.

This quirky tale forms the basis for “Operation Mincemeat,” a musical that debuted in London’s West End and later transitioned to Broadway, where it garnered attention. The musical performs well, particularly due to its cost-effective five-member cast, including Mariah Copeland, Kate Kleiger, Luke Antony Neville, Erin Ramirez, and Jake Bentley Young. These performers are highly skilled and entertaining. The tour, which stops at the CIBC Theatre in 2026-27, maintains much of the original Broadway production’s quality, though sound clarity could improve, especially given the rapid flow of lyrics carrying the story.

Composed by David Cumming, Felix Hagan, Natasha Hodgson, and Zoë Roberts, collectively known as SpitLip, “Operation Mincemeat” appeals to a niche audience with its combination of comedy and sophistication. It presents an amusing narrative akin to “Johnny English,” Monty Python, or Austin Powers but anchored in a World War II setting. The musical creatively explores intelligence agency work, challenging gender stereotypes while offering insights into the personalities behind wartime strategies.

Central to this exploration is the character Hester Leggett, portrayed by Neville, who stands out in the emotionally resonant Act 1 song “Dear Bill.” This number touches on missing a loved one, humanizing the narrative and honoring veterans. The performance of “Dear Bill” showcases impressive emotional depth, contributing significantly to the musical’s emotional impact. Despite certain moments in Act 2, the musical promises humor and cleverness, drawing connections to shows like “Hamilton” and musical elements reminiscent of “Billy Elliot” and “Six.”

“Operation Mincemeat” provides an engaging experience for those interested in wartime stories or the zany brilliance associated with James Bond films. With its light-hearted and thoughtful approach, the musical delivers an enjoyable theatrical experience.

The musical is showing at the CIBC Theatre until October 11, with performances running for two hours and 35 minutes. Tickets range from $40-$135, available at 312-977-1700 and broadwayinchicago.com.