A retired police sergeant with nearly three decades in law enforcement has raised concerns about visiting New York City. This follows the announcement by Mayor Zohran Mamdani to dismantle a specialized NYPD unit called the Strategic Response Group (SRG). Retired Sgt. Betsy Brantner Smith, a spokesperson for the National Police Association, expressed hesitation about taking her family to the city under these circumstances.
Mamdani’s decision involves disbanding SRG, a unit of approximately 500 officers. These officers have been handling counterterrorism and crowd control. The mayor’s plan is part of a wider transformation in how the police department manages protests. Mamdani aims to separate counterterrorism efforts from policing demonstrations. Critics argue this could reduce the coordinated response needed for emergencies.
These officers have a history of working together and training. Their expertise in managing active shooter situations and other emergencies is crucial.—Retired Sgt. Betsy Brantner Smith
The upcoming Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade is expected to attract large crowds. Smith warns that disbanding SRG without keeping the current connections could pose risks. However, NYPD Assistant Commissioner Brad Weeks reassured that security for the event would remain unaffected, with changes taking effect later.
The restructuring will see current SRG counterterrorism staff shifted to the Counterterrorism Bureau. This consolidation is intended to maintain capabilities. Mamdani reiterated that protest responses and counterterrorism require different approaches. His overhaul includes new restrictions on police tactics during protests, such as banning tear gas and restricting pepper spray.
A Change.org petition from the National Police Association calls for the restoration of SRG. Within two days, nearly 2,000 individuals signed the petition. In response, Mamdani defended the reorganization, emphasizing safety and differentiating protest management from terrorism threats.
The new Patrol Support Division officers will receive special training while retaining arrest authority. Plans also include a civilian-led unit for de-escalation and mediation by 2028. Mamdani clarified that police presence would remain vital during any violent incidents.
The restructuring has support from activist groups critical of the NYPD’s past protest management. Some activists have applauded Mamdani’s decision, viewing it as a victory which aligns with long-standing criticisms of the NYPD’s tactics.
NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch reassured that essential resources would stay in place for handling substantial threats. Despite pressure, Mamdani applauded this balance, asserting it meets safety while honoring constitutional rights.
Smith appealed to Mayor Mamdani to uphold NYPD’s capabilities to ensure public safety. Meanwhile, opinions remain divided as activist groups praise the move and law enforcement voices caution against potential vulnerabilities.
