Menu

Vahe Shahinian’s Battle Against Merchant Cash Advances

11 minutes ago 0

Vahe Shahinian has been fighting for seven years to recover multimillion-dollar debts after a lending arrangement he claims was fraudulent. Sitting at his desk in his childhood bedroom, Shahinian recalls the emails that marked a turning point in his life. A broker proposed funding his business with a $750,000 line of credit in 2019. At that time, his company was thriving, selling tickets and producing concerts in Los Angeles. However, the offer came with a condition: he had to accept a third of the amount and pay it back in daily $3,600 installments for 30 days before accessing the full amount. He made the payments for 50 days, but the promised credit never arrived.

For seven years, Shahinian has navigated the unregulated merchant cash advance (MCA) industry, now a fast-growing funding source for small businesses. Shahinian’s lawsuit against his funders could be one of the first of its kind to go to trial. Before this ordeal, Shahinian had built his business over 15 years, relying on his background in computer science and aerospace engineering to create a platform for ticketing and seating charts called It’s My Seat. His company grew from selling tickets for local events to producing shows and organizing tours. Like many small business owners, Shahinian self-funded, relying on savings and credit to finance his business endeavors.

A Business in Need

Shahinian had high hopes for his business, seeing years of profitability and growth. However, when his application for a fifth round of American Express merchant funding was denied, he turned to MCAs in desperation. These advances present themselves as quick solutions, promising large sums rapidly but at the cost of high fees, sometimes reaching over 200% annually. Largely unregulated, these advances are not considered loans but rather purchases of future sales, allowing them to avoid many legal constraints.

He needed to secure funds quickly for an upcoming concert tour, leading him to take two MCAs totaling $250,000. While this saved his tour, it also erased all potential profit, counting as a costly lesson. This experience didn’t deter MCA pitches directed at him. He sought traditional loans, but the pitches continued.

The Fateful Offer

One offer promised a line of credit up to $750,000 with a 9% interest rate, which seemed perfect for Shahinian. But when evaluating the offer’s condition—30 days of daily $3,600 payments—it appeared more like an MCA. Without legal advice, Shahinian trusted the broker’s assurance that it was a routine test of his reliability before receiving the line of credit. He paid diligently but the credit never appeared. Shahinian alleges the delays were presented as technical issues.

EIN Cap, in court, argued it never promised loans, asserting it delivered on an MCA, not a line of credit. Shahinian’s bank account eventually hit zero after 40 days of payments, marking the beginning of a severe financial crisis.

A Spiral of Debt

Shahinian’s lawyer, Shane Heskin, describes what occurred as ‘carroting,’ enticing businesses with attractive financing only to switch to MCAs. Many entrepreneurs, especially those new to business and immigrants, fall prey to this tactic. Shahinian continued paying the MCA out of duty but faced severe financial turmoil. With urgent financial needs and empty accounts, he resorted to more MCAs to stay afloat.

A Collapse

The financial strain led Shahinian to lose his home to foreclosure. He had borrowed against his credit and home equity, ending over $1 million in debt to friends and family. As the MCA payments overwhelmed him, he canceled concerts, and faced mounting losses. Funding companies, including EIN, frequently pursue debt collection, complicating matters further for borrowers.

A Fight or Fold

Unlike most borrowers faced with similar circumstances, Shahinian chose to fight. He filed a lawsuit against EIN Cap in 2019, with the case still delayed in courts. Although MCA companies can be elusive, Shahinian persisted, engaging a private investigator to serve his lawsuit. While some suggested bankruptcy, he views it as defeat, holding on to the belief the false promise led to his downfall.

His fight is motivated by a desire for accountability. Only a handful of states have begun regulating MCA companies, demanding transparency in fees. Despite losing much, Shahinian holds hope that his lawsuit might recover debts estimated at over $5 million. He believes any victory would showcase his integrity and inspire others trapped in similar predicaments.

While Shahinian’s story is a cautionary tale about merchant cash advances, his resilience embodies the spirit of those willing to fight against financial injustice.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *