A man from Long Island faced arrest this week after officials uncovered his alleged deception as a decorated combat veteran. The revelation came as David Agtsteribbe, 58, was accused of stealing $81,000 from a veterans’ organization. His arrest was announced by the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office just days before Veterans Day.
Allegations of Fraudulent Activities
Agtsteribbe reportedly claimed to have received a Purple Heart and painted himself as a wounded war hero. However, prosecutors revealed that he had been discharged as a private from the military in 1988 after only about a year of service. In 1987, Agtsteribbe faced a court-martial and confessed to stealing money from a fellow soldier.
His military record allegedly altered, Agtsteribbe portrayed himself with an honorable discharge. The false credentials allowed him to secure a position as a finance officer at a local veterans’ group, where he is accused of misappropriating funds for personal use.
“There is something particularly despicable about fabricating a military record and claiming honors you have never earned,” said District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney.
Agtsteribbe’s alleged actions involved infiltrating a veterans’ organization and betraying trust by misusing funds meant for veterans. He allegedly misused the money on personal expenses including online shopping, bills, and leisure activities.
Prosecutors Outline the Accusations
Authorities allege that Agtsteribbe joined the Hampton Bays American Legion in 2021 using forged discharge papers. These falsified documents not only gained him membership but also various unwarranted benefits such as free healthcare.
His alleged fraudulent activities began in 2022, involving the transfer of nearly $82,000 from the organization’s account to his own. Prosecutors highlighted that he used the funds for a variety of personal expenditures, including Amazon purchases and private memberships.
The allegations extend beyond this organization. Agtsteribbe had reportedly been seeking memberships in other veterans’ groups since 2019. He even attempted to bypass fees and secure benefits by submitting altered documents to Southampton authorities.
Legal Proceedings and Potential Consequences
The charges against Agtsteribbe include grand larceny, possession of a forged instrument, offering false documents, and falsifying business records. A conviction on these charges could result in a sentence of 25 years to life.
Citing his past criminal history and the severity of current charges, prosecutors requested high bail amounts to ensure his court appearances. Agtsteribbe’s next court appearance is scheduled for November 13, 2026.
Bonny Chu, a writer for Fox News Digital, provided these insights into the ongoing case.