Ann Sather Moves Back to Lakeview and More Changes in Chicago Dining Scene

Less than two weeks after launching a new flagship location between East Village and Wicker Park, Ann Sather, famous for its massive house-made cinnamon rolls, announced its return to Lakeview. The diner will move into the former Stella’s Diner, which shut its doors permanently this week. Former Ald. Tom Tunney, the owner of Ann Sather, had previously closed the Belmont Avenue location after 81 years in June.

Tunney explained that the move into Stella’s was planned for years. He was approached by Stella’s owner, Marvin Barsky, about a potential purchase two or three years ago. Now, with the upcoming expiration of his lease at Broadway and Roscoe, Tunney sees the move as more of a relocation than an expansion.

Stella’s had temporarily closed in July due to a failed city health inspection, which revealed over 50 trapped cockroaches and other violations. The required corrections were made, and the restaurant reopened. Tunney made clear that Stella’s health inspection was not a reason for the move, but rather the lease issue and the Lakeview void prompted the decision.

In preparation for its new chapter, the 3042 N. Broadway location will undergo renovations, including cleaning and structural work with the landlord. Tunney aims to introduce Ann Sather to this space in about eight weeks.

Tunney recently relocated Ann Sather’s Belmont Avenue location to a former Yolk space at 1819 W. Division St. after the property was sold for apartment development. He plans to rehire many Stella’s employees, valuing their customer service and cooking skills.

Marvin Barsky, who also owns Lakeview’s The Bagel Restaurant and Deli, acknowledged the challenges of operating two iconic restaurants. His statement took full responsibility for recent events, emphasizing the responsibility that comes with such establishments. The Bagel also faced a temporary closure due to a health inspection but reopened after compliance.

With the opening of Ann Sather in the former Stella’s space, the diner chain will count four locations by the end of the year, maintaining its rich history since its origins in 1945.

In other news from Chicago’s dining scene, the West Loop’s Wishbone restaurant announced its permanent closure. Owners Joel and Julie Nickson expressed their gratitude to loyal customers and staff over the years. The brunch spot, known for Southern-style cooking, began in 1990 and has served food in Chicago for 36 years. Although the exact closing date is uncertain, Wishbone hopes to feed patrons through the end of August.