Ana Navarro, co-host of The View, expressed surprise when fellow host Sunny Hostin disagreed with her view regarding Governor Gavin Newsom’s decision. The disagreement arose over whether Newsom should have informed victims’ families before he commuted the death sentences of 548 inmates in California. Navarro argued that the families deserved to know in advance.
Navarro stated, “I don’t like the way it went through. He needed to get the approval and agreement of the victims’ families, as those who received commuted sentences were convicted murderers.” She opposed the blanket pardon approach.
In early November, Newsom commuted all death-row inmates’ sentences in California, ending capital punishment, following his earlier executive moratorium on executions.
Citing an ongoing debate, some California prosecutors accused the governor of prioritizing politics over people.
During a The View episode on November 20, 2026, Hostin disagreed with Navarro. Hostin, opposing the death penalty, emphasized that the system is flawed and should not claim lives.
Hostin highlighted statistics: “One innocent individual executed exemplifies the system’s failure.” She referenced statistics showing disproportionate death row impacts on Black individuals.
Co-host Alyssa Farah Griffin sided with Navarro, calling the move a betrayal of families. Griffin argued that families should have been notified in advance to prevent additional trauma.
Griffin speculated that Newsom’s decision might be motivated by political ambitions, suggesting a bid for presidency. Griffin criticized Newsom for not alerting families prior to the announcement.
Co-host Sara Haines urged treating each case individually. Haines argued that the decision to commute all sentences as a blanket approach disregarded victims’ unique circumstances and the closure they sought.
The governor’s office referenced a letter from Newsom explaining his decision. Newsom acknowledged the difficulty of the decision and the potential distress for victims’ families. He defended the action as morally just, stressing it was within his duty. He respected voters’ decision to keep the death penalty law but highlighted the need for clemency.
Y. David Scharf from Morrison Cohen LLP criticized the decision, stating that victims’ rights were overlooked. He emphasized the need for treating affected families with respect and providing them with the opportunity to express their views.
Hanna Panreck, an associate editor at Fox News, contributed to this report.

Highlights from Recent News Stories
Former Press Secretary Criticizes GOP’s Election Strategies
Trump and Cornyn Clash Over Judicial Nomination
Ted Cruz and James Talarico Discuss Texas Space Academy Proposal
Newly Proposed Legislation Aims to Ease Family Travel
Trump Open to Bipartisan Health Care Plan with Democrats