Giants’ Malik Nabers Defended by Former Coach Amid Criticism

Giants wide receiver Malik Nabers faced scrutiny from former player and TV analyst Greg Olsen, who criticized Nabers’ demeanor on the sideline during a recent game. In response, former Giants defensive coordinator Wink Martindale spoke out in defense of Nabers, dismissing Olsen’s critique.

Martindale, who parted ways with the Giants in 2024, showed support for Nabers during an appearance on the ‘Talkin’ Ball’ podcast hosted by Giants insider Pat Leonard. Martindale suggested that such criticism could be a tactical move potentially aimed at affecting Nabers’ future contract negotiations. He encouraged Nabers to maintain his performance, stating, “I’m with Malik on this. Somebody put that in his ear, whether it’s to keep his contract down for the next year when they want to extend him or whatever it is, I don’t know. But just keep playing.”

During the Giants’ game against Philadelphia, Olsen and his broadcasting partner Joe Davis commented on what they perceived as Nabers’ negative body language after a drive that ended with a touchdown by Isaiah Likely. Olsen argued that while competitive players demand the ball, there is a line not to be crossed that affects team success. “It just can never cross that it feels like it takes away from the success of your teammates,” Olsen said. He added that Nabers should celebrate his teammates’ achievements on the field.

Martindale, familiar with friction within the Giants organization, dismissed the idea that Nabers’ attitude was problematic. Referring to John Harbaugh, Nabers’ coach, he remarked on the attention such situations garner in New York but noted it was not new for Harbaugh. Despite past tension in the Giants locker room, including Martindale’s own exit after disagreements with head coach Brian Daboll, Nabers’ commitment remains strong according to his teammates.

Following the game with five receptions for 43 yards, Nabers’ fellow Giants players defended him as a “good teammate.” Running back Cam Skattebo highlighted Nabers’ competitive nature, noting it is valued within the team. Giants fans also continued to show their support for Nabers, reflecting confidence in his abilities and contributions on the field.