J.J. McCarthy’s Struggles Continue Amid Quarterback Competition

J.J. McCarthy Faces Challenges in Minnesota

The journey of J.J. McCarthy with the Minnesota Vikings has not been smooth. Selected as the 10th overall pick in 2024, McCarthy’s rookie year took a hit due to a torn meniscus. This setback allowed Sam Darnold to step in, guiding the team to a 14-3 record in the regular season.

2025: High Hopes and Setbacks

In 2025, expectations rose for McCarthy, but the team faced a decline, ending with a 9-8 record and missing the playoffs. McCarthy was sidelined by a high ankle sprain, affecting his time on the field. Despite winning six out of ten games he started, McCarthy’s performance showed 11 touchdowns against 12 interceptions.

Kyler Murray Joins the Vikings

Heading into the 2026 season, the Vikings acquired Kyler Murray, a Heisman Trophy winner and former first overall pick. Murray won the starting position over McCarthy.

Competition for Backup Position

Recent reports from Alec Lewis of The Athletic indicate McCarthy might lose even his backup position. Carson Wentz, seen as a veteran with potential despite past setbacks, is McCarthy’s competition. Wentz has had stints with teams like Indianapolis, Washington, Los Angeles, and Kansas City.

Alec Lewis noted, “McCarthy took all of the No. 2 reps in last week’s joint practices, his performance was up and down. Wentz’s operation appeared more professional.”

If McCarthy cannot secure the backup spot, he may need to seek opportunities with another team.

Vikings’ Strategic Changes

Training camp has offered insights into the team’s direction. Lewis remarked, “Expect the Vikings to play more from the shotgun in 2026.” The staff is focusing on Murray’s strengths to reshape the passing game, critical for a franchise that hasn’t won a playoff game since 2019.