Ice Cream Maker Showdown: How Ninja Creami Stacks Up Against Competitors

In 2023, my colleague Zoe Malin tested and reviewed the Ninja Creami. At that time, the appliance was hard to find as it was selling out quickly at popular retailers like Costco and Best Buy. Today, the beloved Ninja Creami is more accessible, and the brand has introduced new versions including the Ninja Slushi and Ninja Creami Soft Serve Maker. Despite new entries into the market, the original Ninja Creami remains popular. Social media is filled with recipe ideas from food influencers using this appliance.

Competition has grown. Many brands have launched ice cream makers at lower price points. At $229, Ninja Creami competes with brands like Cuisinart, KitchenAid, and Nutribullet, which offer cheaper alternatives. Some newer models, like the GreenPan Frost, provide features the Ninja Creami lacks, such as eliminating overnight freezing.

Ninja Creami vs. Competitors

I teamed up with Malin to test several ice cream makers, assessing how they perform compared to the Ninja Creami. Our list included Cuisinart Fast Freeze, Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker, KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment, Nutribullet Chill, and GreenPan Frost.

Best Overall Ice Cream Maker: The Ninja Creami was sent to me for testing. It was my first choice for its popularity and extensive reviews. It uses a cream cheese base instead of the typical egg base in its recipe booklet. Freezing the ice cream base for 24 hours is necessary for desired texture. It comes with dishwasher-safe pints and a mixing bowl with a handle.

After testing, I confirm it lives up to the hype, rating it 9.9 out of 10 (minus points for loudness). Setup was straightforward, and the quick-start guide was helpful. After day-long freezing, it produced ice cream in about ten minutes. The texture was creamy and smooth, even without tempering. It compares well to store-bought ice cream, though loudness can be an issue.

Aside from pre-sets for different frozen treats, Fernandez appreciates Ninja Creami’s convenience.
Courtesy of Cory Fernandez

Cuisinart FastFreeze Ice Cream Maker: Cuisinart provided this lightweight, compact appliance. Similar in pre-sets to Ninja Creami, it requires manual effort, using a handle that’s pushed up and down to mix ice cream. Despite requiring manual labor, it closely matches Ninja Creami’s texture. It’s more budget-friendly and ideal for small spaces.

This appliance mixes ice cream efficiently and is preferred by some coworkers.
Courtesy of Cory Fernandez

KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment: Malin tested this attachment with her stand mixer, making setup simple. Although lacking pre-sets, she found it easy to use. It is perfect for baking enthusiasts with limited kitchen space. Note that it requires owning a KitchenAid Stand Mixer.

Ease of use and space-saving design make this attachment perfect for homemade ice cream.
Courtesy of Zoe Malin

Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker: This appliance provides traditional ice cream, ideal for egg-based recipes. Its straightforward design helps achieve creamy textures without icy granules. It lacks customization but scores high in simplicity and efficiency.

This traditional appliance delivers creamy ice cream quickly and easily.
Courtesy of Cory Fernandez

GreenPan Frost Ice Cream Maker: Known for its non-toxic cookware, GreenPan offers diverse applications such as soft serve and milkshakes. It requires no advance freezing, using electrical freezing during mixing. The texture can be customized using a front dial, and parts are dishwasher safe.

Its versatility in frozen treat preparation makes it suitable for soft serve enthusiasts.
Courtesy of Cory Fernandez

Nutribullet Chill Ice Cream Maker: Known for personal blenders, Nutribullet’s appliance mixes automatically, accommodating soft fruits or sorbet mixes well. While ice cream consistency may remain soft, it’s compact and suitable for small spaces.

This compact option excels at producing fruit-based frozen treats.
Courtesy of Cory Fernandez

Testing Approach

Our evaluation focused on setup, ease of use, and ice cream consistency:

• Setup: Most appliances were easy to set up with minimal fuss. The Cuisinart model stood out for simplicity.
• Ease of Use: The Ninja Creami and Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker offered user-friendly operation with helpful guides.
• Ice Cream Texture: Smooth and creamy textures were key. The Ninja Creami and Cuisinart FastFreeze performed best.

Choosing the Right Ice Cream Maker

Choosing an ice cream maker depends on personal preferences:

• Ninja Creami: Offers variety and creamy texture but operates loudly.
• Cuisinart FastFreeze: Compact with presets but requires manual effort.
• KitchenAid Attachment: Needed additional mixer, ideal for bakers.
• Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker: Perfect for traditional, simple ice cream.
• GreenPan Frost: Suitable for soft serve and frozen beverages.
• Nutribullet Chill: Great for sorbet and fruit treats in small spaces.

FAQs

There are alternatives to the Ninja Creami at various price points, each meeting different needs.

• Cuisinart FastFreeze is compact and fits small spaces well.
• GreenPan Frost caters to those who prefer soft serve without pre-freezing.
• Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker is best for traditional, store-bought style ice cream.
• Nutribullet Chill specializes in sorbets and fruit-based desserts.

Why Trust NBC Select?

As a commerce editor with NBC Select, I cover kitchen and home appliances extensively. This expertise comes from eight years writing about food and kitchen appliances. Tested ice cream makers were courtesy samples from noted brands, with assistance from colleague Zoe Malin, contributing further insights.

Stay updated with NBC Select’s comprehensive coverage across social media platforms.