CIC Theater’s Journey to a New Home in Chicago

Improv comedy is a unique art form where mistakes turn into opportunities, especially in Chicago’s vibrant scene. For Farrell Walsh, who serves as the artistic and managing director of CIC Theater, this is a guiding principle that informs his approach both on stage and in running the theater. He sees each setback as a chance to reassess goals and identify future directions.

Despite the seemingly dramatic term “disaster,” Walsh explains it’s how he tackles challenges, “one disaster at a time.” CIC Theater aims for silliness, not subtlety. For over three years, Walsh has been leading the theater towards a new permanent location after closing their long-standing space at 1422 W. Irving Park Road in 2022.

Walsh began his journey with CIC in the early 2000s, initially as a performer and then as artistic director. CIC started with improvised and sketch shows on weekends at The Cornservatory. In 2005, CIC moved to its home at Irving Park. When COVID struck in 2020, the theater faced a crisis but survived thanks to their landlord allowing reduced rent. However, when new landlords took over in 2022, the promise of a new lease didn’t materialize, prompting CIC to leave their Irving Park location.

CIC returned to its roots, becoming nomadic once more. They arranged a deal with Finley Dunne’s Tavern on Lincoln Avenue to use its backroom for performances twice a week. Wednesdays featured student teams and guest performers, while Thursdays hosted open-stage events.

Even without a permanent space, CIC maintained its classes near the former location. Walsh emphasizes the importance of keeping the community engaged. CIC stands out by focusing on “playing vertically,” where scenes inspire subsequent ones, creating a cohesive performance.

In late 2025, CIC parted ways with Finley Dunne’s. They scouted over 100 locations in Lakeview and North Center. Rental costs or build-out expenses rendered each unsuitable. Inspired by their time at Finley Dunne’s, Walsh aimed for a space combining a bar and theater. He found 4301 N. Western Avenue, formerly the Celtic Crown. This location includes a bar, kitchen, and theater space.

Walsh and partner Kyle McCabe launched The Western Bar & Kitchen in July 2025. After extensive renovations, CIC is gearing up to invite their community back. Walsh stresses the importance of community support, aligning with their nonprofit mission. A successful GoFundMe raised over $25,000 for the new venue.

Classes and activities at The Western continue as Walsh and the CIC team plan a grand opening in the fall. Given the community’s enthusiasm, an empty audience is unlikely. CIC’s journey is a testament to resilience and creative improvisation.

Ryan P.C. Trimble is a freelance writer.