John Smoltz on MLB’s Need to Avoid a Work Stoppage

Major League Baseball faces a crucial moment as the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) with the MLB Players Association is nearing expiration. World Series champion John Smoltz emphasized that the sport cannot afford a work stoppage. He believes the impending negotiations require careful handling to prevent negative impacts on baseball.

Smoltz, during an interview with Fox News Digital, mentioned, “If an agreement isn’t reached, baseball will suffer. A stoppage could undo the recent successes and enthralling games the World Series has showcased.” His remarks underscore the urgency for both parties to find common ground.

Smoltz highlighted MLB’s push for a salary cap, a proposal the MLBPA strongly opposes. He noted a significant issue with competitive balance in the league, pointing to teams like the Dodgers and Mets whose spending habits reflect current disparities.

“Baseball’s competition problem is partly intentional, leading to a tipping point where teams, like the Dodgers, spend excessively. Despite such investment, championships aren’t guaranteed,” Smoltz remarked, referencing the Dodgers’ back-to-back World Series titles in 2024 and 2025—the first since the Yankees in the late 1990s.

Smoltz also questioned the effectiveness of a single new system in resolving baseball’s issues. “Without teams committed to fielding their best lineups, dictating expenses in a free market remains challenging,” he said.

The sport has seen a shift, with a younger roster making the bulk of the earnings while seasoned players face short-lived careers. Smoltz pointed out that other sports with salary caps haven’t necessarily fostered competition, leading to “super teams,” particularly in the NBA.

In their initial formal proposals, both MLB and the MLBPA took a stance on critical salary aspects. The MLBPA’s first proposal was met with MLB’s counteroffer, advocating for both a salary cap and salary floor. However, further proposals have stalled.

Last month, MLB reported a 44% rise in viewership for national broadcasts compared to the previous year—the best in nearly a decade. Smoltz hopes this momentum can continue provided both sides reach an agreement, ensuring baseball’s growth and popularity remain steadfast.

Smoltz’s career spanned 21 MLB seasons, most notably with the Atlanta Braves. He also played for the St. Louis Cardinals and Boston Red Sox, retiring with a 213-155 record, a 3.33 ERA, and 154 saves. Currently, he prepares to participate in the American Century Championship in Lake Tahoe, a tournament covered by NBC and Peacock.