A columnist for Kentucky’s largest newspaper, Joseph Gerth of the Louisville Courier Journal, has shared his critical view of Senator Mitch McConnell’s career, calling it a ‘pre-obituary.’ Gerth accuses McConnell, former Republican Majority Leader, of undermining civil rights protections and supporting President Donald Trump despite privately criticizing him. Gerth’s column aimed to comment on McConnell’s influence while he is still alive, sidestepping criticisms of speaking ill of the deceased.
The idea emerged after Republican South Carolina Senator Lindsey Graham passed away on July 11, with criticisms often met with objections due to Graham’s recent death. In the column, Gerth likens McConnell to President Richard Nixon, describing both as detestable figures, suggesting McConnell never faced accountability for his actions.
Gerth highlighted McConnell’s obstruction of President Barack Obama’s Supreme Court nominee, Merrick Garland, in 2016, followed by his push for Amy Coney Barrett’s confirmation shortly before the 2020 election. He argued these actions eroded the Supreme Court’s credibility, citing polls indicating a drop in approval ratings.
McConnell’s Recent Health Timeline
McConnell’s absence from public view since June 11 has sparked talk about his health status, fueled by calls to change Congressional health disclosure rules. His office cited a fall and pneumonia for his absence, though suspicions linger due to past health issues.
Mitch McConnell’s Career in Congress
McConnell joined the Senate in 1984, pioneering Republican success in Kentucky for decades. Initially involved in civil rights movements, he shifted to power with pivotal legislative wins, like Trump’s 2017 tax reform. His alignment with Trump soured post-2020 election, despite supporting his 2024 campaign. McConnell announced he wouldn’t seek another Senate term in 2025.
McConnell Absence Sparks Push To Change Congress Rules
McConnell’s absence and other lawmakers’ has stirred debate on mandatory health disclosures in Congress. Democratic Rep. Ritchie Torres plans to introduce legislation for notifying constituents about extended absences.
The Duty of Transparency Act would require formal notices for absences greater than expected, detailing duration and capability to perform duties. Currently, Congress isn’t obliged to explain voting absences unless voluntarily provided.
Senators Beyond Retirement Age
McConnell’s hospitalization and Graham’s sudden death have highlighted Senate ages, with the average now at 65. Over a third are 70 or older, with fitness for office rarely questioned until health crises arise.
Of the 99 senators, the average age is 65, median is 66. Thirty-six are 70+, eight are 80+, with Chuck Grassley, the oldest at 92, asserting his capabilities through continued farming.
The Senate divides nearly equally by age across parties. Republicans average 64.9 years, Democrats 64.6, but Republicans have more senators 70 or older.
List: Senators 70 and Older
Thirty-six Senate members are 70+, detailed from oldest to youngest:
- Chuck Grassley, 92, Republican, Iowa
- Bernie Sanders, 84, Independent, Vermont
- Mitch McConnell, 84, Republican, Kentucky
- James E. Risch, 83, Republican, Idaho
- Richard J. Durbin, 81, Democrat, Illinois
- Edward J. Markey, 80, Democrat, Massachusetts
- Jeanne Shaheen, 79, Democrat, New Hampshire
- Ron Wyden, 77, Democrat, Oregon
- Elizabeth Warren, 77, Democrat, Massachusetts
- Charles E. Schumer, 75, Democrat, New York
- John Cornyn, 74, Republican, Texas
- Rick Scott, 73, Republican, Florida
- Mark R. Warner, 71, Democrat, Virginia

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani Faces Scrutiny Over Association with Controversial Outlet
Democratic Party Shifts in Michigan During Primaries
Trump Warns Iran of Strong U.S. Response if Talks Fail
Democratic Primary Uncertainties in Michigan
Democratic Senate Primary and Progressive Ambitions in Michigan
Democrats Clash Over Party’s Future in Michigan Primary