The Anoka-Hennepin school board is poised to decide the future of its social and emotional learning (SEL) curriculum after a protracted discussion and vote delay. This decision is occurring amidst ongoing disputes about educational practices related to SEL in schools.
The board is facing pressure to determine what role, if any, SEL should play in Minnesota’s largest school district. Board Member Matt Audette expressed strong opposition to external SEL programs, preferring locally developed ones that can be more closely monitored. He referred to existing programs as potentially harmful.
Conversely, Board Co-chair Kacy Deschene argued for SEL, pointing out studies showing its academic benefits. She noted widespread support among parents and teachers for existing district programs, asserting that any issues were more about perception than reality.
Despite requests, board members did not comment further on their positions.
“Social and emotional learning is about helping students build practical skills,” stated Faith Miller, an associate professor at the University of Minnesota. She highlighted that educational issues are increasingly politicized, yet emphasized that SEL should not be controversial.
Understanding Social and Emotional Learning
Social and emotional learning involves teaching students to manage emotions, set goals, establish relationships, and make responsible decisions. This concept has roots in character education programs from the 1980s and 1990s.
In response to events like the Columbine school shooting, states including Minnesota began to include SEL in educational guidelines. Minnesota, in particular, integrated SEL into efforts to improve student safety and reduce bullying, a move encouraged by federal pandemic relief policies.
SEL Curriculum in Anoka-Hennepin
The district has adopted two curricula over the past five years. “Leader in Me” is used in three elementary schools, drawing on principles from “The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People.” Other schools employ “CharacterStrong,” focusing on themes like kindness and wellness.
CharacterStrong lessons are typically held during morning gatherings and involve activities designed to foster social skills and relationships. The aim is to create a shared language for students and teachers to continue these discussions throughout the day.
“If you saw these lessons in action, it would seem very straightforward,” explained Tom Shaw, director of student services. “This approach involves caring adults looking to support students’ friendships and social skill development.”
Controversy Surrounding SEL
While historically bipartisan, SEL became a flashpoint during the pandemic and racial equity discussions in 2020. Concerns arose about SEL aligning with liberal ideologies. Clarifications have been made that Anoka-Hennepin’s SEL program does not incorporate “transformative SEL,” which addresses inequities related to identity and race.
Parental Opinions and Research Insights
A 2021 survey found many parents back SEL principles but are wary of its terminology, fearing it might conceal liberal agendas. Locally, an Anoka-Hennepin survey revealed strong support for SEL among parents and educators, despite challenges related to time constraints.
Research supports SEL’s benefits, with a 2011 study noting an 11 percentile-point improvement in academic achievement for students in evidence-based SEL programs. In the 2023-2024 school year, over 60% of U.S. public schools utilized formal SEL curricula.
Future Decisions for Anoka-Hennepin
The board has deferred its decision on SEL but may conclude the matter soon. There is interest in developing a district-specific SEL curriculum through staff or an independent contractor. Superintendent Cory McIntyre urged the board to prioritize SEL, emphasizing its critical role in enhancing student achievement.

Teaching Assistant in Los Angeles Arrested for Child Molestation
Princeton Student Detained by U.S. Immigration After Conference
Clarification of Policy on LGBTQ+ Discussions in Liverpool Central School District
Minnesota School District Faces Deadlock Over Ethnic Studies Curriculum
Marine Veteran Faces Investigation Over JROTC Allegations
Decline in NYC Public School Enrollment Sparks Concerns