President Trump’s ambassador to Canada, Pete Hoekstra, is under scrutiny, facing calls for his removal. Over 285,000 Canadians signed a petition accusing him of political interference. This petition, spearheaded by former Green Party leader Elizabeth May, urges Prime Minister Mark Carney’s government to label Hoekstra as persona non grata. The petition suggests his comments about Canada potentially becoming America’s 51st state, among other issues, undermine Canada’s sovereignty.
Elizabeth May expressed concerns to Newsweek about Hoekstra’s suitability for his diplomatic role. She suggested that his actions might intentionally harm relations between Canada and the U.S. She criticized Hoekstra’s approach, comparing him unfavorably to previous U.S. ambassador David Wilkins, who was well-received during his term from 2005 to 2009.
Sponsorship vs. Support
It’s important to note that an MP sponsoring a petition does not imply support. Under Canadian parliamentary tradition, MPs can act as intermediaries for petitioners without endorsing their views. When presenting a petition, MPs cannot debate its merits.
In August, May clarified on Montreal Now that she was not ‘behind the petition’ and did not express a personal stance on it. Her role was to provide Canadians a platform to voice concerns, regardless of her personal opinions.
May emphasized that Canadian sentiment towards their southern neighbors remains largely positive. However, the large number of signatures on the petition indicates dissatisfaction with Hoekstra’s actions.
Prime Minister’s Stance
Prime Minister Mark Carney has resisted calls to expel Hoekstra, citing the necessity of maintaining diplomatic ties despite the strained relations under President Trump’s administration. Carney emphasized the importance of U.S.-Canada trade and security ties, explaining that it is crucial to deal with the current administration as it is.
In response to questions about Hoekstra’s actions, Carney stated, “It’s an administration that we have to work with.”
Petition Details
The petition, initiated by Calgary resident Leanne Walker, lists several accusations against Hoekstra. These include his remarks on Canada’s federal election and comments perceived as siding with Alberta separatists.
The petition also highlights concerns about a voter identification application allegedly used by Alberta separatists and meetings between Alberta Prosperity Project members and U.S. officials. Hoekstra denied awareness of these issues in his diplomatic conduct.
Despite accumulating over 285,000 signatures, the petition cannot compel Hoekstra’s removal. Under Canada’s parliamentary rules, the petition can be formally presented but the government is not obligated to act on its demands.
Decision on Persona Non Grata
Canada has the authority to declare a foreign ambassador persona non grata under the Vienna Convention. Such a move would require Washington to recall Hoekstra or cease his diplomatic functions.
Previous instances of Canada exercising this authority include the expulsion of a Chinese diplomat in 2023 and Indian diplomats in 2024, both related to allegations of interference and violence targeting Canadians.
However, expelling Hoekstra could lead to a diplomatic standoff at a time when Carney seeks to negotiate a trade deal with Washington. The Prime Minister has previously noted that Canada will not respond to every provocative statement from Trump.
A spokesman for the U.S. State Department said the department is aware of the petition but declined further comment. Newsweek has reached out to Global Affairs Canada for response as well.

Highlights from Recent News Stories
Pentagon Releases Declassified UFO Files with Intriguing Plans and Reports
Sinaloa Violence Erupts After Capture of Cartel Leader
Trump, Xi, and Putin’s Shenzhen Meeting Echoes Historic Yalta Conference
Trump Urges Nvidia to Reinstate Huang Amid Controversy
Canada and China Strengthen Trade Relations Amid U.S. Tensions