Chicago White Sox Contemplate Moves Amid Contention Push

The Chicago White Sox find themselves in an unexpected position, striving for postseason contention while nurturing young talent. Initially, a .500 season felt ambitious, yet American League parity and a successful May have surpassed expectations. Their current .523 winning percentage, standing at 34-31, places them fourth in the AL. They’re balancing a mix of promising youngsters with veteran players.

General Manager Chris Getz is considering becoming a buyer at the trade deadline. Yet, he insists on not compromising future goals for short-term success. With slugger Munetaka Murakami sidelined for a month, this team has limited time to prove their postseason worth. By the All-Star break, Getz should have enough evidence to decide whether to pursue aggressive moves.

Examining Key Decisions

As the Sox face the Atlanta Braves, questions arise for Getz:

1. Should Hagen Smith be called up?

White Sox pitcher Hagen Smith practices during spring training on February 15, 2025.

Hagen Smith, a top pitching prospect, has allowed only three earned runs in his last three Triple-A outings over 14 innings, striking out 25 batters. His ERA sits at 3.78 with 72 strikeouts over 47 2/3 innings. Concerns remain about his 33 walks, yet he’s showing positive progress. A potential major league debut could come as early as Sunday against the Dodgers.

His promotion could add depth to the rotation, particularly with Noah Schultz on the injured list. David Sandlin’s recent struggles have raised the need for stability. Utilizing Erick Fedde on Tuesday provides Davis Martin extra rest, but the rest of the rotation is yet to be confirmed.

2. Is acquiring a short-term catcher needed?

Brewers catcher Gary Sánchez hits a two-run homer off Rockies reliever Jaden Hill.

Current Sox catchers are struggling offensively, combining for a .176 average and .263 on-base percentage. With Kyle Teel still far from returning, Getz faces a decision. Acquiring help like Brewers backup Gary Sánchez or Cubs starter Carson Kelly could provide an offensive boost. Alternatively, waiting for Teel’s return remains an option.

3. Should Jacob Gonzalez shift to shortstop?

Jacob Gonzalez discusses with teammates during a game against the Tigers on May 31, 2026.

Manager Will Venable suggested no immediate need to shift Jacob Gonzalez from his current roles. However, shifting Colson Montgomery to third might open opportunities for Gonzalez to gain experience at short. With Murakami’s absence, using Gonzalez in multiple positions might benefit the team.

4. Can Andrew Benintendi be traded?

Braden Montgomery takes batting practice during spring training on February 17, 2026.

Andrew Benintendi, on a substantial five-year deal, faces trade hurdles due to his contract and underperformance. However, recent improvement shows potential. If sustained, a trade could be considered, potentially for prospects like Braden Montgomery. Montgomery’s rising performance in Triple-A signals readiness; however, patience remains until other roster movements occur.

Getz remains focused on developing players while maintaining competitive goals, juggling immediate decisions with a long-term vision for the White Sox.