Revamping the NFL’s Kicking Game

1 week ago 0

Harrison Butker of the Chiefs demonstrated outstanding skill with a 69-yard field goal during pre-season. Modern kickers consistently show improved performance, kicking higher, farther, and straighter. Despite this, the kicking game lacks excitement and predictability.

1. Transforming Field Goals

Introducing a crossbar at the top of the field goal posts could revitalize the game. This would require kickers to accurately place the ball between the uprights without over-kicking. Such a change could make the process more thrilling, removing the routine nature of 38-yard kicks and extra points. Currently, every professional kicker can comfortably hit 70-80 yard field goals during practice. Most coaches are willing to take risks from beyond 50 yards.

2. Rethinking Game Start

Eliminate the opening coin toss and kickoffs. Instead, start the game with a sprint competition. One player from each team lines up at a goal line; they race to recover the ball at midfield. The winner begins possession at their own 20-yard line. If neither retrieves it inbounds, the home team starts at the 50-yard line.

3. Changing Post-Score Play

Once a team scores, let them keep the ball at their 35-yard line. They have one play to gain 20 yards to retain possession. If they fail, the opposing team takes control. This method also substitutes the traditional on-side kick. Most teams might prefer punting, typically resulting in the ball landing near the 20-yard line. This approach offers more strategy and excitement compared to standard kickoffs.

4. Amending Overtime Rules

Current overtime favors teams with strong kickers and first possession. Instead, adopt college playoff rules where each team gets a possession, eliminating the coin toss. The home team chooses initial actions and alternates if tied. This continues until a winner emerges.

Such changes would inject unpredictability and engagement, demanding more strategy, skill, and speed. They could be tested in the next pre-season. Additional suggestions include adopting larger, safer helmets and removing long halftime shows to focus on the game.