Green Mill Transitions to New Owners After 40 Years of Legacy

Located near the intersection of Lawrence and Broadway, the Green Mill is a legendary nightclub and tavern, known for its historical charm. The iconic venue is set to celebrate its 40 years under the leadership of Dave Jemilo on June 19, marking a new chapter in its storied history as ownership transitions to familiar hands.

Jemilo, who first took on the role of owner in 1986, is stepping away, entrusting the Green Mill to Jason Cole and Jill Skintges. This decision brings relief to frequent patrons who were anxious following Jemilo’s announcement of the sale last summer after buying adjacent retail spaces for $5 million in 2021.

“This place has been my life for more than 40 years,” said Jemilo, expressing gratitude and confidence in handing over the reins. “It was time. Nothing dramatic. I just don’t think I have the energy to be here every day until sometimes four in the morning.”

Cole and Skintges represent a continuity of the Green Mill’s legacy. Cole, a seasoned bartender and manager since his college days, and Skintges, a former Joffrey Ballet dancer and math teacher, have been integral to the venue for decades.

Owning a tavern is no small feat. It required months of meticulous planning and discussions with legal and financial advisors. Jemilo humorously noted that some of the silent partners involved in the deal are well-acquainted with the name, having been regular fixtures at the venue.

The Green Mill has seen its share of history. Jemilo first encountered the place as a teenager, hearing stories from his father. When the opportunity arose, he purchased the venue, despite its then-decrepit state, and nurtured it back to prominence.

Larry Kart, the Tribune’s jazz critic, sang the venue’s praises upon its grand opening under Jemilo, highlighting its welcoming atmosphere and ideal music setting. Jemilo’s vision was straightforward: a cash-only, pretension-free space that celebrated diverse musical acts. One of the earliest, Marc Kelly Smith’s Uptown Poetry Slam, continues its global impact today.

Smith reflected on the nurturing environment Jemilo created: “Dave gave a lot of people needing a chance a life-changing direction.” His sentiment is echoed by musicians like Joannie Pallatto and Bradley Parker Sparrow, who appreciated Jemilo’s support for the jazz community and up-and-coming talents.

The Green Mill’s dynamic history dates back to its opening in 1907 as Pop Morse’s Roadhouse. It experienced various revivals and hardships, functioning as a speakeasy and facing rough patches until Jemilo revived it. With writings and documentaries detailing this colorful past, the Green Mill remains a cherished venue in Chicago.

Paul Carr, who documented the Green Mill’s journey in a film, praised Jemilo’s ethical approach to business, highlighting the successful careers launched from the venue.

Looking ahead, Cole and Skintges are prepared to embrace the challenges of maintaining the tavern’s charm, upholding Jemilo’s legacy. Despite retiring, Jemilo retains a sentimental connection, with a tattoo of the venue’s emblematic statue on his arm, symbolizing his enduring bond.

Now residing in Wisconsin and planning a trip to Alaska, Jemilo reflects on his journey filled with personal triumphs and new beginnings, including his marriage to Rosemeire, a connection sparked within the walls of the Green Mill.