Kathy Garver Critiques ‘Family Affair’ Remake

Kathy Garver shared her strong opinion about the unsuccessful 2002 attempt to remake “Family Affair”. In an interview with Fox News Digital, Garver, known for her role as Cissy in the original series, discussed why the reboot failed to capture the charm and bonding that made the classic show special.

“Excuse my language, but it sucked,” Garver said. She attributed the failure to multiple reasons, emphasizing the lack of chemistry and family dynamics that characterized the original.

The original “Family Affair” aired in 1966. It portrayed Bill Davis, a bachelor who became the unexpected guardian of his deceased brother’s children – Cissy, Buffy, and Jody. The show featured Brian Keith as Bill and Sebastian Cabot as the butler, Mr. French.

In the 2002 remake, Gary Cole took on the role of Bill Davis, with Tim Curry as Mr. French. Garver acknowledged their talents but noted that they brought different energies to the roles, making it hard for audiences attached to Keith and Cabot’s original portrayals.

Garver explained, “I think it’s very difficult to do a remake.” Audiences who recognized Gary Cole might think, “Well, that’s not Uncle Bill.” She noted Cole’s excellence in “NCIS,” yet stated that he wasn’t Brian Keith, a dynamic figure whose tough exterior contrasted with his caring nature for the children.

As for Mr. French, Garver felt Tim Curry’s performance diverged significantly from Cabot’s subtle demeanor. She described Curry’s take as “loud and boisterous,” unlike Cabot’s “low-key” portrayal. Cabot’s role was steeped in love for the children, an element Garver believed was missing in the remake.

The original cast’s authenticity made a difference. Garver stressed how genuine the family feeling was, contributing to the show’s success and setting it apart from other sitcoms. The show was groundbreaking as it showed a single relative taking care of three orphaned children.

Garver cited the production quality as a significant factor in the original’s success. “Family Affair” was among the early sitcoms filmed in color, and several cast and crew members had film industry experience, providing a quality touch.

She also highlighted the timeless nature of the original series’ relatable characters and story arcs, which still resonate today. The show’s enduring appeal lies in its ability to address family issues calmly and understandingly.

On the subject of the original series’ warmth, Garver conveyed how important the interactions and chemistry among the cast members were. She praised creator Ed Hartman for his insight into acting with genuine emotion.

As “Family Affair” approaches its 60th anniversary, Garver is preparing to host a marathon event on Catchy Comedy. The celebration will include eight selected episodes, allowing viewers to reminisce over memorable storylines and characters.